Why In News?
Data from the Controller General of Accounts (CGA) shows that the Union government's gross tax collections grew by only 6.1% in April–September.
What Is The Status of Current Fiscal?
Revenue Side
|
Item |
Trend In April–September FY 2026–27 |
|
Gross tax collections |
Grew 6.1%, slightly below the Budget's full-year assumption |
|
Direct taxes |
Healthy growth, with corporate tax stronger than personal income tax |
|
Union excise duty |
Fell to ₹1.07 lakh crore, from ₹1.38 lakh crore a year earlier, after duty cuts on petrol and diesel |
|
Customs duty |
Rose a strong 16.5% in the first half, partly offsetting excise losses |
|
Disinvestment |
₹55,757 crore raised so far, plus ₹6,366 crore from asset monetisation |
IDBI Bank Sale: Fairfax Financial Holdings has been selected to buy a 60.72% stake in IDBI Bank for ₹52,878 crore. With this, the ₹80,000 crore disinvestment target is likely to be exceeded.
Expenditure Side
-
Capex Slowdown: Capital expenditure grew 23.7% in the first quarter, but slowed sharply to 2.8% in the second quarter.
-
Subsidy Overshoot: CareEdge Ratings expects the fertiliser subsidy to rise to ₹2.5–2.7 lakh crore, against the budgeted ₹1.7 lakh crore.
Deficit Outlook
-
Budget Target: Fiscal deficit of 4.3% of GDP.
-
Expected Range: CareEdge Ratings expects 4.3–4.5% of GDP.
-
Possible Gap: SBI economists estimate the deficit could be about ₹1.2 lakh crore higher, due to excise losses and higher fertiliser and petroleum/LPG subsidies.
Key Fiscal Concepts
|
Concept |
Meaning |
|
Fiscal deficit |
Total expenditure minus total receipts excluding borrowings; shows how much the government must borrow |
|
Revenue deficit |
Revenue expenditure minus revenue receipts |
|
Primary deficit |
Fiscal deficit minus interest payments |
|
Capital expenditure |
Spending that creates assets, such as roads and railways |
|
Disinvestment |
Sale of government stake in public sector firms; a non-debt capital receipt |
|
Fiscal slippage |
When the actual deficit exceeds the budgeted target |
Institutional Framework
-
FRBM Act, 2003: The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act sets rules for fiscal discipline.
-
N.K. Singh Committee (2017): The FRBM Review Committee recommended a general government debt target of 60% of GDP (40% Centre, 20% States) and a fiscal deficit of 3% of GDP.
-
New Debt Anchor: From FY 2026–27, the Centre shifted its focus to bringing debt down to about 50% (±1%) of GDP by FY 2030–31.
-
CGA: The Controller General of Accounts, under the Ministry of Finance, publishes monthly accounts of the Union government.
Recent Fiscal Path
-
COVID Peak: The fiscal deficit peaked at about 9.2% of GDP in FY 2020–21.
-
Gradual Consolidation: It has since been brought down steadily, with a target of 4.4% for FY 2025–26 and 4.3% for FY 2026–27.
Why Does Fiscal Discipline Matter?
Fiscal discipline—the practice of keeping government revenues and expenditures in a sustainable balance—matters because it forms the bedrock of economic health, market confidence, and long-term stability.
-
Macroeconomic Stability: It prevents government spending from drastically outpacing tax receipts, reducing the likelihood of runaway inflation and sudden currency depreciation.
-
Controlling Public Debt: Strict financial guardrails prevent a compounding accumulation of national debt, which otherwise forces governments to divert massive shares of future budgets just to pay off interest.
-
Lower Borrowing Costs: When a government manages its finances responsibly, financial markets view it as creditworthy, keeping sovereign and long-term interest rates lower for both the state and private borrowers.
-
Avoiding Crowding Out: Uncontrolled government borrowing can "crowd out" the private sector, consuming capital that businesses might otherwise use for investments, hiring, and innovation.
-
External Sector Protection: Large, persistent fiscal deficits often spill over into a wide current-account deficit, draining foreign exchange reserves and weakening the local currency in global markets.
-
Credibility and Foreign Investment: Predictable, transparent public financial management builds institutional credibility, which significantly attracts foreign direct investment (FDI), especially during periods of global economic uncertainty.
What Are The Key Challenges?
Slowing Tax Revenue Growth
-
Subdued Growth: Gross tax collections grew only 6.1% in the first half, below the Budget's assumption.
-
Policy-Driven Losses: Tax relief measures have reduced revenue.
-
Example: The Union Budget 2025–26 raised the income tax exemption threshold to ₹12 lakh under the new regime, and GST rates were rationalised into mainly two slabs in 2025. Both boosted consumption but reduced tax collections.
Excise Losses From Fuel Price Relief
-
Revenue Hit: Excise collections fell from ₹1.38 lakh crore to ₹1.07 lakh crore in the first half after duty cuts on petrol and diesel.
-
Oil Price Vulnerability: High global oil prices force a difficult choice between protecting consumers and protecting revenue.
Rising Subsidy Bill
-
Fertiliser Subsidy Overshoot: The fertiliser subsidy may exceed its budget by ₹0.8–1 lakh crore, according to CareEdge Ratings.
-
Global Price Shocks: Higher global prices of fertilisers, gas and LPG raise subsidy costs.
Capex Slowdown
-
Weakening Momentum: Capex growth fell from 23.7% in Q1 to 2.8% in Q2.
-
Easy Target For Cuts: When deficits rise, governments often cut capex first, which can hurt long-term growth.
High Debt And Interest Burden
-
Large Interest Payments: About a quarter of Union spending goes to interest, limiting fiscal flexibility.
-
Debt Target Pressure: Slippage would make the 50% debt-to-GDP goal by FY 2030–31 harder to meet.
Uncertain Non-Tax And Disinvestment Receipts
-
One-Off Gains: Large disinvestment receipts, such as the IDBI sale, cannot be relied on every year.
-
History Of Missed Targets: Disinvestment targets were missed in several earlier years, showing their unpredictability.
Balancing Growth And Prudence
-
Competing Pressures: Cutting spending too sharply may slow growth, while overspending risks credibility.
-
Example: In 2022, the UK's unfunded tax-cut "mini-budget" triggered a bond market crisis and a sharp fall in the pound, showing how markets punish perceived fiscal indiscipline.
What Is The Way Forward?
Smart Expenditure Rationalisation
-
Protect Capex: Rationalise revenue spending first, rather than cutting productive capital spending.
-
Review Schemes: Merge overlapping schemes and cut low-impact spending.
Reform Subsidies
-
Better Targeting: Use DBT and data analytics to target subsidies to those who need them.
-
Balanced Fertiliser Use: Reduce overuse of urea through the Nutrient Based Subsidy approach and promote nano urea and organic alternatives.
-
Example: Introducing DBT in fertiliser subsidy in 2018, linking sales to Aadhaar-authenticated point-of-sale machines, improved tracking and reduced diversion.
Strengthen Tax Revenue
-
Widen The Tax Base: Use data analytics, AIS and GST data to bring more taxpayers into the net.
-
Improve Compliance: Reduce GST evasion through e-invoicing and better enforcement.
Use Asset Monetisation Effectively
-
Monetisation Pipeline: Use the National Monetisation Pipeline 2.0 to raise funds from public assets without selling them.
-
Strategic Disinvestment: Continue well-planned stake sales, following the IDBI example.
Manage Oil Price Shocks Prudently
-
Calibrated Duties: Adjust fuel taxes gradually and temporarily, so that relief does not permanently erode revenue.
-
Energy Diversification: Reduce oil import dependence through ethanol blending, renewables and EVs.
Strengthen Fiscal Institutions And Transparency
-
Independent Fiscal Council: Consider an independent Fiscal Council, as suggested by the FRBM Review Committee, to assess fiscal performance and forecasts.
-
Transparent Accounting: Disclose off-budget borrowings and contingent liabilities clearly.
Protect Growth While Consolidating
-
Gradual Consolidation: Follow a credible, gradual glide path rather than sudden cuts.
-
Learn From Crises: Countries that ignored fiscal warnings faced severe crises.
-
Example: Sri Lanka's 2022 debt default followed years of tax cuts, rising debt and falling reserves, underlining the importance of fiscal prudence.
Conclusion
India's fiscal position in FY 2026–27 is a balancing act: strong customs and disinvestment receipts on one side, and weak excise revenue, slowing capex and rising subsidies on the other. Meeting the 4.3% deficit target will require smart spending rationalisation that protects capital investment, better-targeted subsidies, stronger tax collection and prudent handling of oil price shocks, all while keeping India on its path to lower debt.
Source: INDIANEXPRESS
|
PRACTICE QUESTION Q. What factors raise the risk of fiscal slippage in FY 2026–27? Discuss their implications for the Indian economy. (10 Marks, 150 Words) |