Why In News?
An Indian Express column examines the 2001 Kutch earthquake, highlighting how Gujarat transformed the disaster into an institutional and housing reconstruction model for crisis response.
What are Earthquakes?
An earthquake is the sudden shaking or trembling of the Earth's surface caused by a rapid release of stored energy in the Earth's crust or upper mantle.
-
Hypocentre (Focus): The exact point inside the Earth's crust where the earthquake originates and energy is released.
-
Epicentre: The point on the Earth’s surface vertically above the hypocentre; it experiences the seismic waves first and suffers maximum immediate intensity.
-
Fault: A sharp break or fracture in the crustal rocks along which blocks of rock slip past each other.
Causes of Earthquakes
-
Tectonic Causes (Most Common): The Earth’s lithosphere is divided into tectonic plates that constantly move. Friction locks them at boundaries, building up strain until the rock ruptures and snaps along a fault (explained by the Elastic Rebound Theory).
-
Convergent boundaries: Cause deep and destructive megathrust earthquakes (e.g., Himalayas).
-
Divergent boundaries: Associated with normal faults and usually lower magnitudes.
-
Transform boundaries: Lateral sliding (e.g., San Andreas Fault).
-
Volcanic Causes: Associated with tectonic slips or magma movement beneath active volcanoes.
-
Anthropogenic (Human-Induced) Causes: Mining blasts, nuclear tests, fracking, and reservoir-induced seismicity (e.g., the 1967 Koyna earthquake in Maharashtra or the 2008 Sichuan earthquake linked to water loading in large dams).
Seismic Waves
When an earthquake occurs, it radiates energy in different types of waves:
-
Body Waves (Travel through the Earth's interior):
-
Primary Waves (P-waves): Fast, longitudinal/compressional waves that travel through both solids and liquids.
-
Secondary Waves (S-waves): Slower, transverse waves that travel only through solids (crucial for mapping Earth's liquid outer core shadow zone).
-
Surface Waves (Travel along the ground surface):
-
Love and Rayleigh waves: Slowest-moving waves, restricted to the surface, and responsible for the most structural damage and destruction.
Measurement Scales
-
Richter Scale / Moment Magnitude Scale: Measures the magnitude (total energy released) on a logarithmic scale (0 to 10+).
-
Mercalli Intensity Scale: Measures the intensity of shaking and visible damage on a scale from I to XII.
Earthquake Vulnerability and Zonation in India
-
India's Risk: Roughly 59% of India's land area is vulnerable to moderate to severe earthquakes.
-
Seismic Zonation (BIS / Bureau of Indian Standards): India is divided into four seismic zones:
-
Zone V (Very High Risk): Himalayan belt, North-East India, Rann of Kachchh, Andaman & Nicobar Islands.
-
Zone IV (High Risk): Parts of Jammu & Kashmir, Delhi, Bihar, Indo-Gangetic plains, parts of Maharashtra.
-
Zone III (Moderate Risk): Parts of peninsular plateau, southern India.
-
Zone II (Low Risk): Relatively stable stable shields (parts of southern/central India)
What Was The Scale Of The 2001 Kutch Earthquake?
-
Deaths: The earthquake caused over 13,000 deaths and widespread destruction of housing across the epicentral region. It was India's worst earthquake in more than 50 years.
-
Houses And Villages: Over 1.2 million houses in 8,000 villages and 490 towns were damaged or destroyed, and 400,000 collapsed completely.
-
Public Infrastructure: Around 12,000 schools and 2,000 health facilities were damaged. In Kutch alone, 1,234 schools and 7,424 classrooms were damaged.
-
Economic Loss: Total property damage was estimated at $7.5 billion.
-
Historic Risk: A similar-scale earthquake had struck Bhuj and Anjar in 1819, with about 2,000 deaths.
-
Urban Failure: The Japan International Cooperation Agency study attributes the death toll partly to the scale of the quake and the progress of urbanisation in nearby cities. Multi-storey buildings collapsed in Gandhidham and Ahmedabad.
How Did Gujarat Rebuild?
-
Policy Framework: Four months after the earthquake, the state announced the Gujarat Earthquake Reconstruction and Rehabilitation Policy.
-
Settlement Choices: Communities could choose partial relocation or in situ reconstruction.
-
Institution Building: The Gujarat State Disaster Management Authority (GSDMA) was formed and owner-driven reconstruction was adopted in the state's policy framework.
-
Legal Backing: Gujarat became the first state in India to enact the Gujarat State Disaster Management Act 2003 to give a legal framework for reconstruction, rehabilitation and risk mitigation.
-
External Finance: The World Bank and Asian Development Bank provided loans worth $300 million and $500 million respectively.
What Is Owner-Driven Reconstruction?
-
Core Idea: Affected families rebuild their own houses with financial aid and technical support, instead of contractors building for them. It gives households control over design and timing.
-
Local Knowledge: The Hunnarshala Foundation combined traditional building practices with seismic-resistant techniques, reducing costs and construction time.
-
Revival Of Vernacular Forms: The reconstruction process drove the resurgence of traditional bhunga-style buildings.
-
Build Back Better: The rehabilitation phase aimed to build back better using owner-driven reconstruction for sustainable development.
Initiatives Taken By Government For Disaster Risk Reduction And Reconstruction
-
Gujarat State Disaster Management Authority: Created after the earthquake to coordinate reconstruction, rehabilitation and risk reduction. It became the model for state authorities across India.
-
Disaster Management Act, 2005: The Act created the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), state authorities and district authorities. It shifted India from relief-centred to preparedness-centred management.
-
National Disaster Response Force: A specialised force raised under the 2005 Act for search, rescue and relief. It has battalions across the country trained for earthquakes and floods.
-
National Building Code And Seismic Zoning: The Bureau of Indian Standards revised earthquake design standards, and the country is divided into seismic zones II to V. Compliance determines how new buildings resist shaking.
-
Coalition For Disaster Resilient Infrastructure: India launched the global coalition in 2019 to promote resilient infrastructure. It extends lessons on safe building to partner countries.
What Are The Key Challenges In Crisis Response And Rebuilding?
Uneven Recovery Outcomes
-
Winners And Losers: A study of the Gujarat reconstruction examined who gained and who lost from recovery. Those with land, assets and organisation recovered faster than the poor.
-
Marginal Groups: Tenants, landless households and informal workers had weaker claims to housing aid.
Weak Building Compliance
-
Urban Collapse: Multi-storey buildings in Gandhidham and Ahmedabad collapsed despite the distance from the epicentre. Poor construction and weak enforcement raised deaths.
-
Retrofitting Gap: Large older housing stock remains unsafe in seismic zones. Rural and semi-urban builders rarely follow codes.
Slow Rebuilding Of Public Services
-
Schools And Health: The loss of 1,234 schools in Kutch left children without classrooms. Temporary structures stayed in use for long periods.
-
Health Capacity: Rebuilding health facilities as earthquake resilient took years of investment.
Livelihood Loss
-
Craft And Small Industry: Kutch's crafts and small units lost workshops and market links. Cottage industries needed targeted revival packages.
-
Rural Economy: Dry grazing land and low incomes meant households had thin savings to recover.
Planning And Land Constraints
-
Relocation Disputes: Communities weighed partial relocation against in situ rebuilding. Land titles and plot sizes were contested.
-
Weak Local Capacity: Town planning for hundreds of damaged towns depended on external consultants. Municipal capacity was thin.
Dependence On External Finance
-
Loan Burden: Reconstruction relied on loans of $300 million and $500 million from multilateral banks. This added to the state's debt.
-
Coordination: Many agencies worked in parallel, so coordination and information sharing were difficult.
What Is The Way Forward For Crisis Response And Rebuilding?
Institutionalise Disaster Authorities
-
Permanent Bodies: Keep state authorities funded and staffed before disasters strike. GSDMA's creation and the 2003 Act show the value of legal backing.
-
Pre-Approved Policy: Prepare reconstruction policy templates in advance so that packages are announced within weeks, not months.
Scale Up Owner-Driven Models
-
Technical Support: Provide trained masons, engineers and facilitators to families rebuilding. Support combined with funds speeds rebuilding.
-
Vernacular Safety: Promote traditional techniques made seismic-resistant, as in the bhunga revival. They reduce cost and time.
Enforce Seismic Building Codes
-
Strict Compliance: Make third-party structural audits compulsory for multi-storey buildings in high seismic zones. Link permits to certified design.
-
Retrofitting Drive: Retrofit schools, hospitals and lifeline buildings first. Fund retrofits through low-interest loans.
Plan Cities With Hazard Maps
-
Damage And Risk Mapping: Use plot-level hazard maps to guide land use and heights, as done in Bhuj.
-
Participation: Run public consultations on relocation and plot allocation. Include women and marginal groups.
Protect Livelihoods Alongside Housing
-
Enterprise Revival: Offer grants and credit for crafts and small industries within months.
-
Insurance: Expand disaster insurance for homes and micro-enterprises.
Strengthen Coordination And Preparedness
-
Single Window: Use one agency to coordinate government, donors and civil society. Share a common damage database.
-
Drills And Training: Train communities, schoolchildren and responders regularly. Link with the NDRF and local volunteers.
Learn From Global Frameworks
-
Sendai Framework: Align national plans with the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030, which promotes "build back better".
-
Resilient Infrastructure: Use the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure to share design standards.
Conclusion
Kutch showed that disasters can become a chance to build back better through owner-driven reconstruction, strong institutions and legal backing. Equitable livelihood recovery, enforced building codes and preparedness must be sustained to protect lives in the next earthquake.
Source: INDIANEXPRESS
|
PRACTICE QUESTION Q. Disasters can be an opportunity to build back better. Discuss with reference to the Kutch earthquake. (10 Marks, 150 Words) |