Why In News?
The Punjab Assembly passed resolutions to demand an equitable share in Yamuna waters and about ₹1.44 lakh crore in royalty from Rajasthan for using Sutlej, Ravi and Beas waters.
Key Demands Passed in the Resolutions
Yamuna Water Share: Reaffirmed Punjab's claim to an equitable share of Yamuna River waters, arguing that parts of Punjab fall within the Yamuna basin and noting that Punjab was left out of the 1994 Yamuna water-sharing MOU between Delhi, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, and Rajasthan.
Royalty from Rajasthan: Demanded approximately ₹1.44 lakh crore in outstanding royalty from Rajasthan for using Sutlej, Ravi, and Beas waters, tracing the claim back to a pre-1960 economic agreement with the erstwhile Bikaner State under which water charges were previously paid.
Control of Headworks: Demanded control over key irrigation headworks (Ropar, Harike, and Ferozepur).
Repeal of Dam Safety Act: Demanded the repeal of the Dam Safety Act, 2021, claiming it infringes upon the federal structure since water is a state subject.
Ravi Water Utilization: Proposed new projects to harness Ravi River waters that currently flow unutilized toward Pakistan.
What Is The Background Of The Dispute?
The Indus Waters Treaty
-
Eastern Rivers To India: Under the Indus Waters Treaty, 1960, India got exclusive use of the eastern rivers, the Ravi, Beas and Sutlej.
How Allocations Changed
|
Year |
Event |
Allocation (Million Acre-Feet, MAF) |
|
1955 |
Inter-State agreement on 15.85 MAF of surplus Ravi–Beas water |
Rajasthan 8.0, undivided Punjab (incl. PEPSU) 7.2, J&K 0.65 |
|
1966 |
Punjab Reorganisation Act creates Haryana |
Water rights of successor States left to the Centre |
|
1976 |
Centre's notification splits Punjab's 7.2 MAF |
Punjab 3.5, Haryana 3.5, Delhi 0.2 |
|
1981 |
Tripartite agreement on 17.17 MAF |
Punjab 4.22, Haryana 3.5, Rajasthan 8.6, Delhi 0.2, J&K 0.65 |
|
1987 |
Eradi Tribunal report |
Punjab 5.0, Haryana 3.83, Rajasthan 8.6 |
Sutlej–Yamuna Link (SYL) Canal
-
Purpose: The 214-km SYL canal was planned to carry Haryana's share of Ravi–Beas water across Punjab. About 122 km lies in Punjab and 92 km in Haryana.
-
Foundation: Work began in 1982 at Kapoori village in Patiala district.
-
Status: Haryana has completed its portion, but Punjab's portion remains unfinished.
Key Milestones
-
Rajiv–Longowal Accord (1985): Agreed that a tribunal would verify the States' claims and that the SYL would be completed.
-
Eradi Tribunal (1986): Set up under the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956, it gave its report in 1987. A further report is still awaited.
-
Violence Halts Work: Construction stopped in 1990 after militants killed engineers working on the canal.
-
Supreme Court Orders (2002, 2004): The Court directed Punjab to complete the canal.
-
Punjab Termination of Agreements Act, 2004: Punjab unilaterally cancelled its water agreements.
-
Presidential Reference (2016): In November 2016, the Supreme Court held the 2004 Act unconstitutional.
-
Mediation: Since then, the Court has maintained the status quo and asked both States to negotiate, with the Centre as mediator.
Yamuna Question
-
1994 MoU: The Upper Yamuna waters are shared among Uttar Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Haryana, Rajasthan and Delhi under a 1994 Memorandum of Understanding. Punjab is not a party.
-
Haryana's Use: Haryana now draws about 6 MAF of Yamuna water.
-
What Are The Positions Of The States?
|
State |
Position |
|
Punjab |
Has no surplus water; Haryana and Rajasthan are not in the Ravi–Beas basin; seeks a Yamuna share and royalty from Rajasthan |
|
Haryana |
Wants its allocated share and completion of the SYL canal, citing binding agreements and court orders |
|
Rajasthan |
Relies on its allocation under the 1955 and 1981 agreements for irrigation and drinking water in desert districts |
Framework On Water Sharing
|
Provision |
Details |
|
Entry 17, State List |
Water, including irrigation and canals, subject to Entry 56 of the Union List |
|
Entry 56, Union List |
Regulation and development of inter-State rivers |
|
Article 262 |
Parliament may provide for adjudication of inter-State water disputes and bar other courts' jurisdiction |
|
Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 |
Provides for tribunals to settle disputes |
|
River Boards Act, 1956 |
Provides for river boards for inter-State rivers |
|
Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966 |
Sections 78–80 govern Bhakra–Beas rights and set up the Bhakra Beas Management Board (BBMB) |
Why Does This Dispute Matter?
-
Agriculture: Punjab and Haryana produce a large share of India's wheat and rice for the central pool, and depend heavily on irrigation.
-
Drinking Water: Rajasthan's desert districts rely on the Indira Gandhi Canal for irrigation and drinking water.
-
Cooperative Federalism: Unresolved disputes strain Centre–State and inter-State relations.
-
National Security And Water Use: Ensuring that eastern-river water is fully used within India matters under the Indus Waters Treaty.
What Are The Key Challenges?
Depleting Groundwater And Water Scarcity
-
Over-Extraction: Groundwater has fallen in about 72% of Punjab's blocks, according to the State's own resolution.
-
Paddy Dependence: Water-intensive paddy, grown on over 30 lakh hectares in Punjab, drains aquifers. Punjab's Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009, which delays paddy transplanting, shows the scale of concern.
Disputed Water Availability Estimates
-
Shrinking Flows: Punjab argues that river flows today are lower than the 1981 estimate of 17.17 MAF, so allocations based on old data are unfair.
-
Outdated Data: The Eradi Tribunal report of 1987 relied on decades-old data, and its final report is still pending, nearly 40 years later.
Defiance Of Agreements And Court Orders
-
Unilateral Action: Punjab's 2004 Act cancelling agreements was struck down in 2016, showing the risk of States defying binding decisions.
-
Land De-Notification: In 2016, Punjab returned land acquired for the SYL to its original owners, after which the Supreme Court ordered status quo.
Delays In Tribunals
-
Long Delays: Inter-State water tribunals in India have often taken decades.
-
Example: The Cauvery dispute tribunal was set up in 1990, gave its final award in 2007, and the Supreme Court settled the allocation only in 2018, showing how long such disputes can drag on.
Politicisation And Regional Identity
-
Emotive Issue: River water has been tied to agrarian distress and Punjabi identity since the 1980s, making compromise politically costly.
-
Recent Flashpoint: In April 2025, the BBMB decided to release 8,500 cusecs of extra water to Haryana. Punjab strongly objected, and the matter went to the Punjab and Haryana High Court.
Unused Water Flowing Out
-
Water Loss To Pakistan: Some Ravi water has flowed across the border due to lack of storage.
-
Example: The Shahpur Kandi dam on the Ravi, completed in 2024 after decades of delay, aims to stop this outflow, showing the value of storage infrastructure.
Weak Institutional Mechanisms
-
Advisory Bodies Lack Teeth: There is no strong, permanent institution to settle disputes quickly or enforce compliance.
-
Lapsed Reform: The Inter-State River Water Disputes (Amendment) Bill, 2019, which proposed a single permanent tribunal, lapsed with the 17th Lok Sabha.
What Is The Way Forward?
Reassess Water Availability Scientifically
-
Updated Hydrological Data: Conduct a fresh, independent assessment of Ravi–Beas and Yamuna flows using modern data and climate projections.
-
Transparent Data Sharing: Make river flow and allocation data public to build trust between States.
Expedite Dispute Resolution
-
Time-Bound Tribunals: Revive the proposal for a single permanent tribunal with fixed timelines.
-
Basin-Level Institutions: Set up permanent river basin authorities.
-
Example: Australia's Murray–Darling Basin Authority, created under the Water Act, 2007, manages water across several States with a basin-wide plan, offering a model for India.
Negotiated Settlement Through Cooperative Federalism
-
Centre-Led Mediation: Use the Centre's mediation, as urged by the Supreme Court, and platforms such as the Zonal Councils and the Inter-State Council.
-
Package Deals: Consider combined agreements covering Ravi–Beas, Yamuna, power sharing and infrastructure funding.
Reduce Water Demand In Agriculture
-
Crop Diversification: Shift from paddy to less water-intensive crops such as maize, pulses and millets.
-
Efficient Irrigation: Expand micro-irrigation under Per Drop More Crop (PMKSY).
-
Example: Punjab's "Pani Bachao, Paisa Kamao" pilot paid farmers for saving electricity used in groundwater pumping, showing how incentives can encourage water saving.
Build Storage And Recharge Groundwater
-
Storage Projects: Complete projects such as the Ujh multipurpose project and Yamuna storage dams like Renuka, Lakhwar and Kishau.
-
Groundwater Recharge: Scale up Atal Bhujal Yojana and Jal Shakti Abhiyan: Catch the Rain.
Strengthen Institutions Like BBMB
-
Fair Representation: Ensure BBMB's composition and decisions are seen as fair by all member States.
-
National Water Framework: Act on the Mihir Shah Committee (2016) recommendation for a restructured National Water Commission to manage water holistically.
Respect The Rule Of Law
-
Honour Agreements And Verdicts: States must comply with binding agreements and court orders, while seeking changes through legal and negotiated routes.
Conclusion
The Punjab–Haryana–Rajasthan water dispute shows how old allocations, shrinking resources and political sensitivities can keep a conflict alive for decades. Punjab's new resolutions reflect real concerns about groundwater depletion, but lasting peace requires updated scientific data, faster dispute resolution, efficient agriculture, more storage and genuine cooperative federalism, rather than unilateral action.
Source: INDIANEXPRESS
|
PRACTICE QUESTION Q. Inter-State water disputes in India reflect a failure of cooperative federalism. Examine with reference to the Punjab–Haryana–Rajasthan dispute and suggest institutional reforms. (15 Marks, 250 Words) |