Why In News?
The Supreme Court, in Mangala Bhimrao Ingle vs Additional Commissioner, Amravati Division (2026 INSC 1193), said laws disqualifying people with more than two children from local body elections have "lost their relevance".
What Was The Case?
-
The Petitioner. Mangala Bhimrao Ingle was elected Sarpanch of Kakoda Gram Panchayat in Maharashtra in 2022.
-
The Disqualification. Her election was set aside under Section 14(1)(j-1) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959, because she had given birth to a third child in 2014.
-
Interim Relief. After facing an unfavorable ruling from the High Court, Ingle appealed to the Supreme Court. The Bench stayed the High Court's order, allowing her to continue as Sarpanch until her civil appeal is resolved.
Key Observations by the Court
-
Demographic Shift: India’s Total Fertility Rate (TFR) has dropped from approximately 3.0 in 2003 to 1.9, falling below the replacement level of 2.1.
-
The Court noted that the fear of overpopulation—the original foundation for these laws—has crumbled, and India now faces a transition toward an ageing population and a shrinking working-age share.
-
Evolving Constitutionality. The Court observed that laws held valid when enacted can become arbitrary or unconstitutional over time if the underlying factual and demographic assumptions materially change.
-
Rights and Representation. The Bench flagged that disqualifying citizens based on family size excludes an entire class from political participation, places a disproportionate burden on women, and infringes upon reproductive autonomy under Article 21.
-
Lack of Uniformity. The judgment pointed out that 15 Indian states do not impose two-child disqualifications for local body elections, nor do such restrictions apply to Members of Parliament (MPs) or Members of Legislative Assemblies (MLAs).
Javed vs State Of Haryana (2003) Case
|
What Is The Constitutional And Legal Framework?
Panchayati Raj
-
73rd Amendment, 1992: Gave constitutional status to Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) through Part IX (Articles 243–243O).
-
Article 243F: Allows State legislatures to prescribe disqualifications for panchayat membership by law.
-
Article 40: A Directive Principle asking the State to organise village panchayats as units of self-government.
Right To Contest Elections
-
Statutory Right: In Jyoti Basu vs Debi Ghosal (1982), the Supreme Court held that the right to vote and contest elections is a statutory, not fundamental, right.
Reproductive Rights
-
Part Of Personal Liberty: In Suchita Srivastava vs Chandigarh Administration (2009), the Supreme Court held that a woman's right to make reproductive choices is part of personal liberty under Article 21.
-
Privacy: K.S. Puttaswamy vs Union of India (2017) recognised privacy, including decisional autonomy over family and procreation, as a fundamental right.
Related Judgment
-
Rajbala vs State of Haryana (2015): Upheld educational qualifications and other conditions for contesting panchayat elections in Haryana, showing the Court's earlier deference to State-imposed eligibility rules.
Where Are Two-Child Norms In Force?
Local Body Elections
-
Several States: States including Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Odisha and Uttarakhand have had two-child conditions for some local body elections.
-
Withdrawals: Some States, including Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh, later withdrew such rules.
-
Example: In November 2024, Andhra Pradesh repealed its two-child rule for local body elections, with the State government citing concerns over falling fertility and an ageing population.
Other Areas
-
Government Jobs And Schemes: Assam's population policy links certain government jobs to a two-child condition.
Centre's Position
-
No Coercion: In a December 2020 affidavit to the Supreme Court, the Union government said India is against coercive family planning and opposed a mandatory two-child policy.
How Has India's Population Policy Evolved?
|
Phase |
Approach |
|
1952 |
India became one of the first countries to launch a national family planning programme |
|
1975–77 (Emergency) |
Coercive sterilisation drives, which caused a lasting public backlash |
|
1994 |
India endorsed the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) Programme of Action at Cairo, shifting to a rights-based approach |
|
2000 |
National Population Policy adopted a target-free, voluntary approach |
Current Demographic Picture
-
Below Replacement: NFHS-5 (2019–21) recorded India's TFR at 2.0.
-
Regional Variation: Fertility ranges from about 1.1 in Sikkim to about 3.0 in Bihar, according to NFHS-5.
-
Ageing: The UNFPA's India Ageing Report 2023 projects the share of elderly people will rise from about 10.5% in 2021 to 20.8% by 2050.
What Are The Arguments For And Against The Two-Child Norm?
Arguments In Favour
-
Leadership By Example: Supporters argue elected representatives should model small families.
-
State Power: Under Article 243F, States can set eligibility conditions, and the right to contest is not fundamental.
-
Regional Pressures: High-fertility regions may still need population stabilisation measures.
Arguments Against
-
Outdated Premise: With TFR below replacement, the rationale has weakened.
-
Hurts Women: Women often lack control over childbearing, yet bear the consequences.
-
Excludes The Poor And Marginalised: Poorer, less educated and rural communities, who tend to have larger families, are disproportionately barred from local leadership.
-
Coercive: It contradicts India's commitment to voluntary, rights-based family planning.
What Are The Key Challenges?
Harm To Women's Political Participation
-
Unequal Burden: Two-child rules can disqualify women elected under reservation, undermining gains in women's representation.
-
Example: Women make up about 46% of India's roughly 31 lakh elected panchayat representatives, and about 21 States provide 50% reservation for women in PRIs, so disqualification rules can affect a large number of women leaders.
Harmful Social Consequences
-
Perverse Incentives: Studies have linked two-child rules to harmful outcomes such as men deserting wives, denial of paternity and sex-selective practices.
-
Gender Imbalance Risk: In a society with son preference, such rules may encourage sex-selective abortion, despite the PCPNDT Act, 1994.
Weak Link To Fertility Decline
-
Development Drives Fertility: Fertility has fallen mainly because of education, women's empowerment, health care and urbanisation, not coercive rules.
-
Example: Kerala achieved low fertility through high female literacy and health care, without coercive measures.
Uneven Demographic Picture
-
North–South Divide: Some northern States still have higher fertility, while southern States face ageing, creating conflicting policy pressures.
Federal And Political Sensitivities
-
Delimitation Concerns: Southern States worry that population-based delimitation after the next Census could reduce their political weight despite controlling population.
-
Pronatalist Turn: Some leaders, such as in Andhra Pradesh, now encourage larger families, reflecting a policy reversal.
Legal Uncertainty
-
Laws Remain In Force: Until the larger bench rules, people in affected States continue to face disqualification, while courts may differ in how they apply the November 2026 observations.
Risk Of Ageing Without Preparation
-
Low Fertility Trap: Very low fertility can lead to labour shortages and pressure on pensions and health systems.
-
Example: South Korea's TFR fell to about 0.72 in 2023, the world's lowest, prompting heavy spending on pronatalist incentives with limited success.
What Is The Way Forward?
Larger Bench Should Reconsider
-
Constitutional Review: The larger bench should examine two-child laws in light of reproductive autonomy, privacy and equality, using current demographic evidence.
States Should Review Their Laws
-
Voluntary Repeal: States with such laws can follow Andhra Pradesh in repealing them, rather than waiting for the courts.
Rights-Based Population Policy
-
Voluntary Family Planning: Strengthen access to contraception, counselling and maternal health care under the National Health Mission.
-
Follow Cairo Principles: Align policy with the ICPD 1994 principle that couples decide freely on the number and spacing of children.
Empower Women
-
Education And Jobs: Invest in girls' education and women's employment, which naturally reduce fertility and strengthen women's agency.
-
Protect Women Leaders: Ensure eligibility rules do not undermine women's reservation in PRIs.
Region-Specific Demographic Strategies
-
Targeted Support: Focus family planning services on high-fertility districts through programmes like Mission Parivar Vikas, launched in 2016 for high-fertility districts.
-
Prepare For Ageing: Low-fertility States should invest in elderly care, pensions and productivity.
Learn From Global Experience
-
Coercion Backfires: Coercive population policies can create long-term problems.
-
Example: China replaced its one-child policy with a two-child policy in 2016 and a three-child policy in 2021, but births have continued to fall, showing that population rules are hard to reverse once social norms change.
Use The Demographic Dividend
-
Skilling And Jobs: Focus on skilling, health and employment for India's large working-age population before it begins to age.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s reconsidering of Javed marks a key shift from 2003 overpopulation concerns to present-day sub-replacement fertility and ageing risks. Today, the two-child rule is outdated and disproportionately impacts women and vulnerable groups. A voluntary, rights-focused model centered on empowerment and targeted strategies is far superior to barring citizens from local governance.
Source: INDIANEXPRESS
|
PRACTICE QUESTION Q. Coercive population measures conflict with constitutional values and democratic participation. Examine this statement with reference to the two-child norm in panchayat elections, and suggest a rights-based alternative. (15 Marks, 250 Words) |