Why In News?
In Surendra Manjhi vs Union of India, the Supreme Court directed that rescued bonded labourers receive immediate financial assistance ordinarily within seven days of a release certificate.
What Is Bonded Labour?
Meaning Of Bonded Labour
-
Definition: Bonded labour is a system in which a person is forced to work to repay a loan or advance, often at little or no wage.
-
Legal Status In India: The Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976 declares this system illegal and frees every bonded labourer from it.
Debt-Based Labour Exploitation
-
Debt As Control: A small loan becomes a tool to control the worker, because high interest and wage deductions keep the debt from ever being repaid. (Source: NHRC)
-
Below Minimum Wage: In PUDR vs Union of India (1982), the Supreme Court held that paying less than the minimum wage amounts to forced labour under Article 23.
Forced Labour In Exchange For Advance Payments
-
Advance Trap: Labour contractors give poor families a cash advance, then bind them to work for months at a brick kiln or farm to repay it.
-
Seasonal Migrants At Risk: Seasonal migrant families are most exposed, because they take advances before leaving home for distant worksites.
Restriction On Freedom Of Movement
-
Loss Of Mobility: Bonded workers cannot leave the employer, change jobs or move freely until the debt is cleared.
-
Confinement Of Families: Employers often hold entire families at worksites, sometimes by retaining identity documents.
Exploitation Through Traditional And Social Obligations
-
Customary Bondage: Traditional systems historically bound labourers to landlords through caste and custom, such as Hali in Gujarat, Jeetham in Karnataka and Kamiya in Bihar.
-
Social Pressure: Caste hierarchy and social obligation can make bondage seem "normal" to both employers and workers.
Inter-Generational Bonded Labour
-
Inherited Debt: Debts are often passed from parents to children, which locks entire families into bondage across generations.
-
Debts Extinguished By Law: The 1976 Act extinguishes all bonded debts, so no such debt can legally be recovered from a worker or their heirs.
Bonded Labour And Human Trafficking
-
Linked Crimes: Many bonded labourers are trafficked across States by recruiters who promise jobs and then hold them in bondage.
-
Penal Provisions: The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 penalises trafficking and unlawful compulsory labour, complementing the 1976 Act.
What Are The Major Directions Issued By The Supreme Court?
-
Seven-Day Rule: Immediate financial assistance under the rehabilitation scheme must ordinarily be paid within seven days of the release certificate.
-
Personalised Plan: An individual rehabilitation plan covering livelihood, housing, education and healthcare is to be prepared within 90 days of rescue.
-
Quick Certification: Once bondage is established, the competent authority must ordinarily issue a release certificate within 24 hours.
-
Language Safeguard: Certificates and information on entitlements must be given in a language the labourer understands.
-
National Format: The Centre must prescribe a uniform format for release certificates that all States and UTs will recognise.
-
NHRC Consultation: The Centre must issue supplementary guidelines, in consultation with the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), within three months.
-
Six-Month Deadline: All States and UTs must comply with the directions within six months, and file affidavits within two weeks after that.
-
Nodal Officers: Every State and UT must designate a nodal officer and set up an inter-State coordination mechanism within six months.
-
Grievance Officer: Every district must name an officer to handle complaints about release certificates and delayed assistance, and resolve them ordinarily within 30 days.
-
Follow-Up: District Vigilance Committees must review each released labourer's rehabilitation for at least one year, to prevent re-exploitation.
Constitutional Framework
|
What Are The Major Challenges In Eradicating Bonded Labour?
Rehabilitation And Payment Delays
-
Rescue Without Relief: Long delays in paying assistance leave survivors without income, which pushes many back into debt and bondage.
-
Example: In Surendra Manjhi vs Union of India, Manjhi was rescued from a brick kiln in 2019 but received his immediate assistance only in 2022.
-
Conviction-Linked Grants: The full ₹1–3 lakh rehabilitation grant is tied to the employer's conviction, but trials are slow and convictions rare.
-
Example: In one case, survivors received release certificates in March 2022 but got the ₹30,000 immediate assistance only around July 2024. Their full rehabilitation was still pending in 2025.
Weak Identification And Monitoring
-
Under-Identification: Many districts do not conduct the periodic surveys funded under the scheme, so bonded labour often goes unrecorded.
-
Paper Vigilance Committees: District and sub-divisional Vigilance Committees often exist only on paper and rarely meet.
-
Poor Data Tracking: Official figures on rescue and rehabilitation often do not match, and there was long no public tracking system.
-
Example: By 2019, India had released 3,13,687 bonded labourers, but 19,962 were listed as "not available for rehabilitation" because they had died or moved without a trace.
Inter-State Migration Gaps
-
Jurisdictional Disputes: Workers rescued outside their home State face confusion over which State must issue certificates and pay assistance.
-
Example: In the Manjhi case, labourers from Bihar were rescued in Uttar Pradesh, and the lack of coordination between the two States delayed payments for years.
-
Seasonal Migrant Vulnerability: Seasonal migrants in brick kilns and farms are recruited far from home, which isolates them from local support.
Structural And Socio-Economic Drivers
-
Debt Traps Through Advances: Labour contractors lure poor families with cash advances that turn into unpayable debts.
-
Caste And Landlessness: Bonded labour falls heavily on landless Dalits and Adivasis, who lack land, savings and bargaining power.
-
Disguised Bondage: Newer arrangements hide bondage behind lump-sum wages or "apprenticeships".
-
Example: Under the Sumangali scheme in Tamil Nadu's spinning mills, young women were promised a lump sum at the end of multi-year contracts, a practice widely criticised as a form of bonded labour.
Weak Enforcement
-
Low Conviction Rates: Employers are rarely convicted, so the law has little deterrent effect.
-
Local Collusion: Ties between employers, contractors and local officials can discourage complaints and rescues.
What Are The Major Government Initiatives Against Bonded Labour?
Legal Measures
-
Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976: The Act abolishes bonded labour, extinguishes all bonded debts and makes District Magistrates responsible for identification, release and rehabilitation.
-
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023: The BNS penalises trafficking and unlawful compulsory labour, supporting prosecution of offenders.
Rehabilitation Scheme
-
Central Sector Scheme For Rehabilitation Of Bonded Labourer–2021: In effect since 27 January 2022, it provides immediate assistance of up to ₹30,000 and rehabilitation grants of ₹1 lakh, ₹2 lakh or ₹3 lakh by category.
-
No State Share: States do not need to contribute matching funds for cash rehabilitation assistance under the revised scheme.
-
District Rehabilitation Fund: Every district must keep a permanent corpus of at least ₹10 lakh for immediate assistance.
-
Surveys And Awareness: The scheme funds district surveys, evaluation studies and awareness campaigns.
-
Track Record: Since 1978, 2,97,038 bonded labourers have been rescued and rehabilitated, with ₹106.25 crore disbursed.
Institutional And Digital Mechanisms
-
NHRC Monitoring: Since 1997, the Supreme Court has entrusted the National Human Rights Commission with monitoring implementation of the 1976 Act.
-
NHRC Advisory (2021): The NHRC's 2021 advisory called for issuing release certificates within 24 hours of rescue, followed by prompt compensation and rehabilitation.
-
Revised SOP (2026): The Ministry of Labour framed a revised Standard Operating Procedure on 14 May 2026, which the Supreme Court has now made binding on all States.
-
NAVJIVAN Portal: The portal records and tracks each case from identification and rescue to release and rehabilitation.
Social Security And Labour Reforms
-
e-Shram Portal: The national database of unorganised workers has over 30 crore registrations, helping link vulnerable workers to welfare schemes.
-
Labour Codes: The Code on Social Security, 2020 and the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 aim to extend social protection to unorganised and inter-State migrant workers.
-
Anti-Human Trafficking Units: The Ministry of Home Affairs supports Anti-Human Trafficking Units in districts to rescue trafficked and bonded persons.
Judicial Interventions
-
Landmark Judgments: In Bandhua Mukti Morcha vs Union of India (1984) and Neeraja Chaudhary vs State of Madhya Pradesh (1984), the Supreme Court held that release without rehabilitation fails the Constitution.
-
PUDR Case (1982): In People's Union for Democratic Rights vs Union of India, the Court held that paying workers below the minimum wage amounts to forced labour under Article 23.
-
Time-Bound Directions (2026): In Surendra Manjhi vs Union of India, the Court fixed timelines of 24 hours for release certificates and 7 days for immediate assistance.
What Is The Way Forward For Eradicating Bonded Labour?
Make Rehabilitation Fast And Dignified
-
Delink Grants From Conviction: The full rehabilitation grant should be paid on proof of bondage, while prosecution continues on a separate track.
-
Interim Subsistence Support: The Centre should adopt the Court-suggested subsistence allowance wherever rehabilitation benefits are delayed.
-
Raise Immediate Assistance: Immediate assistance should be raised and indexed to inflation so that it truly meets a family's basic needs.
-
Livelihood Convergence: District Magistrates should link released workers to rural employment, housing, PDS, land allotment and skilling schemes.
-
Example: Registering released labourers on the e-Shram portal can connect them directly to insurance, pension and welfare schemes for unorganised workers.
Strengthen Enforcement And Deterrence
-
Revive Vigilance Committees: States must ensure district and sub-divisional committees meet regularly and include worker and civil society representatives.
-
Speedy Trials: Summary trials under the 1976 Act and dedicated courts can raise conviction rates and deter offenders. (Source: Ministry of Law and Justice)
-
Publicly Name Offenders: Public lists of employers found using forced labour can raise the cost of exploitation.
-
Example: Brazil's "Dirty List" (Lista Suja) publishes employers caught using slave-like labour and blocks their access to public credit. Along with mobile inspection teams set up in 1995, it has helped free tens of thousands of workers.
Protect Migrant Workers
-
Inter-State Coordination: Origin and destination States should share data, appoint nodal officers and accept a uniform release certificate, as the Court has directed.
-
Regulate Recruitment: Labour contractors and wage advances, especially in brick kilns, should be registered and monitored.
-
Example: Kerala's Aawaz health insurance scheme, launched in 2017, registers inter-State migrant workers and gives them health cover, creating a database to track and support vulnerable workers.
Use Technology And Transparency
-
Real-Time Tracking: A fully working NAVJIVAN Portal with public dashboards should track every case from rescue to final rehabilitation.
-
Grievance Redressal: District grievance officers should resolve complaints about delayed certificates or payments within 30 days, as the Court has ordered
Tackle Root Causes
-
Land And Credit Access: Land reforms and access to formal credit through Self-Help Groups and Kisan Credit Cards can free poor families from moneylenders.
-
Education And Awareness: Awareness campaigns in source districts can help families recognise and report debt traps.
-
Global Commitments: Ending bonded labour advances SDG Target 8.7, which calls for eradicating forced labour and modern slavery.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court has made clear that freedom from bondage must mean lasting dignity, not just rescue. Ending bonded labour needs fast rehabilitation, strict enforcement and protection for migrant workers, in line with Article 23 and SDG 8.7.
Source: THEHINDU
|
PRACTICE QUESTION Q. Why does bonded labour persist in India nearly 50 years after its abolition? (15 Marks, 250 Words) |